Authorities say the move is part of efforts to reflect a more inclusive national identity, but the proposal has divided residents.
The town, which dates back nearly 250 years, is known for its colonial-era architecture and tourism appeal.
Some locals argue the change will do little to improve living conditions, insisting that resources should instead address economic challenges.
Supporters, including members of the Pan Africanist Congress, say the renaming is about correcting historical imbalances and honouring those who resisted apartheid.
However, business owners warn the decision could come at a cost, with concerns over rebranding and potential impacts on tourism.
The dispute reflects a wider national conversation about how to balance heritage with transformation in post-apartheid South Africa.
